Officials with New York's Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) have announced a controversial plan to cull mute swans in the state, drawing angry backlash from birdwatchers and others. The draft plan, announced last week, calls for shooting the birds and destroying their eggs in order to bring their numbers -- now at about 2,200 -- under control.
The DEC maintains that the plan targets "a non-native, invasive species, brought to North America from Eurasia for ornamental purposes in the late 1800s," and says that the goal is to protect other native bird species in the state. They also say that swans exhibit aggressive behavior toward people and other birds, disrupt natural vegetation, push out wild fauna and can potentially endanger airplanes if they get sucked into engines. It's a complicated issue -- wildlife biologists say that the animals disrupt natural environments and should be culled to make way for the species that were originally there. But animal activists argue that shooting them is inhumane -- and that the swans, by right of living on the land for over a century, have just as much right to live there as other species.