5 Things You Didn't Know About New York's Carriage Horses
Riding in a horse-drawn carriage may be the stuff of fairy tales. But what is it like for the horses who work day in and day out? Do horses belong on tightly-packed, polluted city streets? The horse-drawn carriage industry in New York City causes great suffering for horses and routinely puts people's safety in danger. Here are five facts the industry doesn't want you to know.
Under the law, drivers can work their horses nine hours a day, seven days a week. Some drivers have been observed unlawfully forcing the horses to work a "double-shift."
Horses are forced to work in sleet or shine-even when the weather is unbearably hot or freezing cold, breathing in exhaust, and pounding the hard pavement day in and day out. A study from Cornell suggests that asphalt can be up to 50 degrees hotter than outdoor temperatures.
Carriage horses live in stalls half the size recommended for animals their size, when they aren't pounding the pavement. They never have the chance to experience natural horse life, like running and playing in grass-instead they live in tiny stalls in midtown Manhattan.
Since 2006, at least nine carriage horses have died in New York City, some from horrific accidents. Each was younger than 15 years-although horses who are properly cared for ordinarily live between 25 and 30 years.
Horses are terrified of traffic and sudden noises. Many carriage accidents result from horses spooking, like Smoothie who bolted with the carriage still shackled behind her when a man walked past beating a drum; the carriage got caught between two poles and, struggling to move forward, a terrified Smoothie collapsed and died of shock.
So who is looking out for horses? The Animal Legal Defense Fund sued the New York Police Department to obtain public records of carriage-related accidents and injuries. This was bolstered in April 2014 by the New York Supreme Court agreement with ALDF that the public has a right to these records. With no clear records or regulation, this industry's bottom line is not the well-being of horses. A ban on horse-drawn carriages is the only meaningful way to protect the horses.